'잠든 전 여친 강제 성관계' 강간 아니라는 검찰, 법원이 뒤집었다

10 29333 12

xxxtentacion 2023.07.03 16:53

검찰 "연인관계서 상대방 잠 들었을 때 성관계 한다고 범죄 성립되지 않아"

한 여성이 전 남자친구에게 준강간을 당했다며 고소한 사건을 검찰이 불기소 처분을 내린 가운데, 법원은 "기소하는 것이 타당하다"고 결정했다.

서울고법 형사30부(강민구 부장판사)는 20대 여성 A씨가 전 남자친구인 30대 B씨에 대한 불기소 처분에 불복해 낸 재정신청을 지난 4월 인용했다고 3일 밝혔다. 재정신청은 고소·고발인이 수사기관의 불기소 처분에 불복해 법원에 판단을 구하는 제도다.

B씨는 지난 1월 잠이 들었던 전 여자친구 A씨를 성폭행하고 신체를 동의 없이 촬영한 혐의를 받고 있다. 당시 A씨는 몸살 기운데 약을 먹었던 데다 다리를 다친 상태였다.

A씨는 카메라 소리를 듣고 깨어나 B씨의 휴대전화를 뺏고 증거 동영상을 자신의 휴대전화로 전송, 보존했다. 당시 A씨는 형편이 좋지 않아 건강을 회복할 때까지 '신체 접촉을 하지 않는다'는 조건으로 전 연인이었던 B씨 집에 잠시 머물렀다.

하지만 준강간 피해를 당했다는 A씨는 B씨를 준강간치상, 카메라등이용촬영 혐의로 고소했는데 지난해 8월 검찰은 준강간치상 혐의에 대해서는 불기소 처분했다. 검찰은 "부부관계 및 연인관계에서 상대방이 자고 있을 때 성관계를 한다고 해서 곧바로 준강간죄가 성립하지 않는다"고 불기소이유서에 설명했다.

전문 http://n.news.naver.com/mnews/ranking/article/088/0000822940?sid=001

12

HOT

SNS 공유하기

목록으로

Comment

BEST 1 이쁘다 2023.07.04 21:58

그럼 같이살지 말아야지

10 Comments

Array ( [0] => Array ( [wr_id] => 804075 [wr_num] => -217653 [wr_reply] => [wr_parent] => 788918 [wr_is_comment] => 1 [wr_comment] => 10 [wr_comment_reply] => [ca_name] => [wr_option] => [wr_subject] => [wr_content] => 헤어졌잖아... 헤어졌는데 왜 전애인을 다시 찾아 ? 도대체 무슨 마음으로 찾는것이고 받아준것일까? [wr_link1] => [wr_link2] => [wr_link1_hit] => 0 [wr_link2_hit] => 0 [wr_hit] => 0 [wr_good] => 3 [wr_nogood] => 0 [mb_id] => naver_9821094b [wr_password] => *81E8DE13E3A441EDDF9714B6259DC8737AC0C389 [wr_name] => 최상의서비스 [wr_email] => [wr_homepage] => [wr_datetime] => 2023-07-15 17:44:21 [wr_file] => 0 [wr_last] => [wr_ip] => 211.234.192.187 [wr_facebook_user] => [wr_twitter_user] => [articleid] => [wr_1] => [wr_2] => [wr_3] => [wr_4] => [wr_5] => [wr_6] => [wr_7] => [wr_8] => [wr_9] => [wr_10] => [as_type] => 0 [as_shingo] => 0 [as_img] => 0 [as_list] => 0 [as_publish] => 0 [as_extra] => 0 [as_extend] => 0 [as_level] => 8 [as_download] => 0 [as_down] => 0 [as_view] => 0 [as_lucky] => 0 [as_poll] => 0 [as_star_score] => 0 [as_choice] => 0 [as_choice_cnt] => 0 [as_re_mb] => [as_re_name] => [as_tag] => [as_map] => [as_icon] => [as_thumb] => [as_video] => [as_update] => [as_star_cnt] => 1 [ast_read] => 0 [ast_adlist_edate] => 0 [ast_adtop_edate] => 0 [ast_extend] => [ast_ultra_extend] => [wr_besttime] => 2023-07-16 13:17:06.273484 [name] =>

최상의서비스 [is_lock] => [reply_name] => [content1] => 헤어졌잖아... 헤어졌는데 왜 전애인을 다시 찾아 ? 도대체 무슨 마음으로 찾는것이고 받아준것일까? [content] => 헤어졌잖아... 헤어졌는데 왜 전애인을 다시 찾아 ?
도대체 무슨 마음으로 찾는것이고
받아준것일까? [is_secret] => [date] => 1689410661 [datetime] => 23-07-15 17:44 [best] => [ip] => 211.♡.192.187 [is_reply] => [is_edit] => [is_del] => ) [1] => Array ( [wr_id] => 803537 [wr_num] => -217653 [wr_reply] => [wr_parent] => 788918 [wr_is_comment] => 1 [wr_comment] => 9 [wr_comment_reply] => [ca_name] => [wr_option] => [wr_subject] => [wr_content] => 엥??? [wr_link1] => [wr_link2] => [wr_link1_hit] => 0 [wr_link2_hit] => 0 [wr_hit] => 0 [wr_good] => 1 [wr_nogood] => 0 [mb_id] => naver_912b08711 [wr_password] => *1218D21EEF99780F2D6BBD4EB95032F754BE176D [wr_name] => DABIN [wr_email] => [wr_homepage] => [wr_datetime] => 2023-07-15 09:13:38 [wr_file] => 0 [wr_last] => [wr_ip] => 221.154.68.247 [wr_facebook_user] => [wr_twitter_user] => [articleid] => [wr_1] => [wr_2] => [wr_3] => [wr_4] => [wr_5] => [wr_6] => [wr_7] => [wr_8] => [wr_9] => [wr_10] => [as_type] => 0 [as_shingo] => 0 [as_img] => 0 [as_list] => 0 [as_publish] => 0 [as_extra] => 0 [as_extend] => 0 [as_level] => 94 [as_download] => 0 [as_down] => 0 [as_view] => 0 [as_lucky] => 0 [as_poll] => 0 [as_star_score] => 0 [as_choice] => 0 [as_choice_cnt] => 0 [as_re_mb] => [as_re_name] => [as_tag] => [as_map] => [as_icon] => [as_thumb] => [as_video] => [as_update] => [as_star_cnt] => 1 [ast_read] => 0 [ast_adlist_edate] => 0 [ast_adtop_edate] => 0 [ast_extend] => [ast_ultra_extend] => [wr_besttime] => [name] =>

DABIN [is_lock] => [reply_name] => [content1] => 엥??? [content] => 엥??? [is_secret] => [date] => 1689380018 [datetime] => 23-07-15 09:13 [best] => [ip] => 221.♡.68.247 [is_reply] => [is_edit] => [is_del] => ) [2] => Array ( [wr_id] => 793001 [wr_num] => -217653 [wr_reply] => [wr_parent] => 788918 [wr_is_comment] => 1 [wr_comment] => 8 [wr_comment_reply] => [ca_name] => [wr_option] => [wr_subject] => [wr_content] => 돈 필요했나보네... [wr_link1] => [wr_link2] => [wr_link1_hit] => 0 [wr_link2_hit] => 0 [wr_hit] => 0 [wr_good] => 5 [wr_nogood] => 0 [mb_id] => kakao_8d7e08fe [wr_password] => *219BAA5277E328B5B8001645EF21094F682CC0DB [wr_name] => 페인 [wr_email] => moses33@naver.com [wr_homepage] => [wr_datetime] => 2023-07-07 02:24:34 [wr_file] => 0 [wr_last] => [wr_ip] => 219.250.126.140 [wr_facebook_user] => [wr_twitter_user] => [articleid] => [wr_1] => [wr_2] => [wr_3] => [wr_4] => [wr_5] => [wr_6] => [wr_7] => [wr_8] => [wr_9] => [wr_10] => [as_type] => 0 [as_shingo] => 0 [as_img] => 0 [as_list] => 0 [as_publish] => 0 [as_extra] => 0 [as_extend] => 0 [as_level] => 146 [as_download] => 0 [as_down] => 0 [as_view] => 0 [as_lucky] => 0 [as_poll] => 0 [as_star_score] => 0 [as_choice] => 0 [as_choice_cnt] => 0 [as_re_mb] => [as_re_name] => [as_tag] => [as_map] => [as_icon] => [as_thumb] => [as_video] => [as_update] => [as_star_cnt] => 1 [ast_read] => 0 [ast_adlist_edate] => 0 [ast_adtop_edate] => 0 [ast_extend] => [ast_ultra_extend] => [wr_besttime] => 2023-07-08 08:54:33.370600 [name] =>

페인 [is_lock] => [reply_name] => [content1] => 돈 필요했나보네... [content] => 돈 필요했나보네... [is_secret] => [date] => 1688664274 [datetime] => 23-07-07 02:24 [best] => [ip] => 219.♡.126.140 [is_reply] => [is_edit] => [is_del] => ) [3] => Array ( [wr_id] => 790272 [wr_num] => -217653 [wr_reply] => [wr_parent] => 788918 [wr_is_comment] => 1 [wr_comment] => 7 [wr_comment_reply] => [ca_name] => [wr_option] => [wr_subject] => [wr_content] => 헐.. [wr_link1] => [wr_link2] => [wr_link1_hit] => 0 [wr_link2_hit] => 0 [wr_hit] => 0 [wr_good] => 1 [wr_nogood] => 0 [mb_id] => kakao_96f4095a [wr_password] => *5CD3C63E7100BF6C24294708E445D6C7BB297BAC [wr_name] => 김1 [wr_email] => [wr_homepage] => [wr_datetime] => 2023-07-04 22:02:22 [wr_file] => 0 [wr_last] => [wr_ip] => 106.102.142.151 [wr_facebook_user] => [wr_twitter_user] => [articleid] => [wr_1] => [wr_2] => [wr_3] => [wr_4] => [wr_5] => [wr_6] => [wr_7] => [wr_8] => [wr_9] => [wr_10] => [as_type] => 0 [as_shingo] => 0 [as_img] => 0 [as_list] => 0 [as_publish] => 0 [as_extra] => 0 [as_extend] => 0 [as_level] => 30 [as_download] => 0 [as_down] => 0 [as_view] => 0 [as_lucky] => 0 [as_poll] => 0 [as_star_score] => 0 [as_choice] => 0 [as_choice_cnt] => 0 [as_re_mb] => [as_re_name] => [as_tag] => [as_map] => [as_icon] => [as_thumb] => [as_video] => [as_update] => [as_star_cnt] => 1 [ast_read] => 0 [ast_adlist_edate] => 0 [ast_adtop_edate] => 0 [ast_extend] => [ast_ultra_extend] => [wr_besttime] => [name] =>

김1 [is_lock] => [reply_name] => [content1] => 헐.. [content] => 헐.. [is_secret] => [date] => 1688475742 [datetime] => 23-07-04 22:02 [best] => [ip] => 106.♡.142.151 [is_reply] => [is_edit] => [is_del] => ) [4] => Array ( [wr_id] => 790261 [wr_num] => -217653 [wr_reply] => [wr_parent] => 788918 [wr_is_comment] => 1 [wr_comment] => 6 [wr_comment_reply] => [ca_name] => [wr_option] => [wr_subject] => [wr_content] => 그럼 같이살지 말아야지 [wr_link1] => [wr_link2] => [wr_link1_hit] => 0 [wr_link2_hit] => 0 [wr_hit] => 0 [wr_good] => 7 [wr_nogood] => 0 [mb_id] => kakao_872707fe [wr_password] => *7F511D86CA63509C1435910730352035564A9273 [wr_name] => 이쁘다 [wr_email] => koreanej@naver.com [wr_homepage] => [wr_datetime] => 2023-07-04 21:58:13 [wr_file] => 0 [wr_last] => [wr_ip] => 218.232.74.80 [wr_facebook_user] => [wr_twitter_user] => [articleid] => [wr_1] => [wr_2] => [wr_3] => [wr_4] => [wr_5] => [wr_6] => [wr_7] => [wr_8] => [wr_9] => [wr_10] => [as_type] => 0 [as_shingo] => 0 [as_img] => 0 [as_list] => 0 [as_publish] => 0 [as_extra] => 0 [as_extend] => 0 [as_level] => 48 [as_download] => 0 [as_down] => 0 [as_view] => 0 [as_lucky] => 0 [as_poll] => 0 [as_star_score] => 0 [as_choice] => 0 [as_choice_cnt] => 0 [as_re_mb] => [as_re_name] => [as_tag] => [as_map] => [as_icon] => [as_thumb] => [as_video] => [as_update] => [as_star_cnt] => 1 [ast_read] => 0 [ast_adlist_edate] => 0 [ast_adtop_edate] => 0 [ast_extend] => [ast_ultra_extend] => [wr_besttime] => 2023-07-07 18:43:18.850754 [name] =>

이쁘다 [is_lock] => [reply_name] => [content1] => 그럼 같이살지 말아야지 [content] => 그럼 같이살지 말아야지 [is_secret] => [date] => 1688475493 [datetime] => 23-07-04 21:58 [best] => 1 [ip] => 218.♡.74.80 [is_reply] => [is_edit] => [is_del] => ) [5] => Array ( [wr_id] => 790111 [wr_num] => -217653 [wr_reply] => [wr_parent] => 788918 [wr_is_comment] => 1 [wr_comment] => 5 [wr_comment_reply] => [ca_name] => [wr_option] => [wr_subject] => [wr_content] => 그집에 들어가서 산다고..? [wr_link1] => [wr_link2] => [wr_link1_hit] => 0 [wr_link2_hit] => 0 [wr_hit] => 0 [wr_good] => 6 [wr_nogood] => 0 [mb_id] => naver_a540097c [wr_password] => *A73D69EB209B5E3DE10B8332954EB0DCEE03899F [wr_name] => Liatris [wr_email] => [wr_homepage] => [wr_datetime] => 2023-07-04 18:53:55 [wr_file] => 0 [wr_last] => [wr_ip] => 117.111.2.249 [wr_facebook_user] => [wr_twitter_user] => [articleid] => [wr_1] => [wr_2] => [wr_3] => [wr_4] => [wr_5] => [wr_6] => [wr_7] => [wr_8] => [wr_9] => [wr_10] => [as_type] => 0 [as_shingo] => 0 [as_img] => 0 [as_list] => 0 [as_publish] => 0 [as_extra] => 0 [as_extend] => 0 [as_level] => 57 [as_download] => 0 [as_down] => 0 [as_view] => 0 [as_lucky] => 0 [as_poll] => 0 [as_star_score] => 0 [as_choice] => 0 [as_choice_cnt] => 0 [as_re_mb] => [as_re_name] => [as_tag] => [as_map] => [as_icon] => [as_thumb] => [as_video] => [as_update] => [as_star_cnt] => 1 [ast_read] => 0 [ast_adlist_edate] => 0 [ast_adtop_edate] => 0 [ast_extend] => [ast_ultra_extend] => [wr_besttime] => 2023-07-07 18:43:21.550116 [name] =>

Liatris [is_lock] => [reply_name] => [content1] => 그집에 들어가서 산다고..? [content] => 그집에 들어가서 산다고..? [is_secret] => [date] => 1688464435 [datetime] => 23-07-04 18:53 [best] => [ip] => 117.♡.2.249 [is_reply] => [is_edit] => [is_del] => ) [6] => Array ( [wr_id] => 789248 [wr_num] => -217653 [wr_reply] => [wr_parent] => 788918 [wr_is_comment] => 1 [wr_comment] => 4 [wr_comment_reply] => [ca_name] => [wr_option] => [wr_subject] => [wr_content] => 사겻다가 헤어진걸 연인관계라고하나? 이혼한 배우자도 포함? [wr_link1] => [wr_link2] => [wr_link1_hit] => 0 [wr_link2_hit] => 0 [wr_hit] => 0 [wr_good] => 2 [wr_nogood] => 0 [mb_id] => kakao_8982091b [wr_password] => *F6E58CA6BCE68BED0C8AC06642CF80169642DC9D [wr_name] => 노란딸기 [wr_email] => [wr_homepage] => [wr_datetime] => 2023-07-04 00:14:24 [wr_file] => 0 [wr_last] => [wr_ip] => 110.8.50.115 [wr_facebook_user] => [wr_twitter_user] => [articleid] => [wr_1] => [wr_2] => [wr_3] => [wr_4] => [wr_5] => [wr_6] => [wr_7] => [wr_8] => [wr_9] => [wr_10] => [as_type] => 0 [as_shingo] => 0 [as_img] => 0 [as_list] => 0 [as_publish] => 0 [as_extra] => 0 [as_extend] => 0 [as_level] => 25 [as_download] => 0 [as_down] => 0 [as_view] => 0 [as_lucky] => 0 [as_poll] => 0 [as_star_score] => 0 [as_choice] => 0 [as_choice_cnt] => 0 [as_re_mb] => [as_re_name] => [as_tag] => [as_map] => [as_icon] => [as_thumb] => [as_video] => [as_update] => [as_star_cnt] => 1 [ast_read] => 0 [ast_adlist_edate] => 0 [ast_adtop_edate] => 0 [ast_extend] => [ast_ultra_extend] => [wr_besttime] => 2023-07-16 08:59:18.976626 [name] =>

노란딸기 [is_lock] => [reply_name] => [content1] => 사겻다가 헤어진걸 연인관계라고하나? 이혼한 배우자도 포함? [content] => 사겻다가 헤어진걸 연인관계라고하나? 이혼한 배우자도 포함? [is_secret] => [date] => 1688397264 [datetime] => 23-07-04 00:14 [best] => [ip] => 110.♡.50.115 [is_reply] => [is_edit] => [is_del] => ) [7] => Array ( [wr_id] => 788960 [wr_num] => -217653 [wr_reply] => [wr_parent] => 788918 [wr_is_comment] => 1 [wr_comment] => 3 [wr_comment_reply] => [ca_name] => [wr_option] => [wr_subject] => [wr_content] => 소설인가? [wr_link1] => [wr_link2] => [wr_link1_hit] => 0 [wr_link2_hit] => 0 [wr_hit] => 0 [wr_good] => 2 [wr_nogood] => 0 [mb_id] => naver_8ea10898 [wr_password] => *128476990595AB5C4C0C3DB1DC117F2CD291FD23 [wr_name] => 야봉 [wr_email] => [wr_homepage] => [wr_datetime] => 2023-07-03 17:55:56 [wr_file] => 0 [wr_last] => [wr_ip] => 106.101.67.53 [wr_facebook_user] => [wr_twitter_user] => [articleid] => [wr_1] => [wr_2] => [wr_3] => [wr_4] => [wr_5] => [wr_6] => [wr_7] => [wr_8] => [wr_9] => [wr_10] => [as_type] => 0 [as_shingo] => 0 [as_img] => 0 [as_list] => 0 [as_publish] => 0 [as_extra] => 0 [as_extend] => 0 [as_level] => 167 [as_download] => 0 [as_down] => 0 [as_view] => 0 [as_lucky] => 0 [as_poll] => 0 [as_star_score] => 0 [as_choice] => 0 [as_choice_cnt] => 0 [as_re_mb] => [as_re_name] => [as_tag] => [as_map] => [as_icon] => [as_thumb] => [as_video] => [as_update] => [as_star_cnt] => 1 [ast_read] => 0 [ast_adlist_edate] => 0 [ast_adtop_edate] => 0 [ast_extend] => [ast_ultra_extend] => [wr_besttime] => 2023-07-16 08:59:21.535682 [name] =>

야봉 [is_lock] => [reply_name] => [content1] => 소설인가? [content] => 소설인가? [is_secret] => [date] => 1688374556 [datetime] => 23-07-03 17:55 [best] => [ip] => 106.♡.67.53 [is_reply] => [is_edit] => [is_del] => ) [8] => Array ( [wr_id] => 788947 [wr_num] => -217653 [wr_reply] => [wr_parent] => 788918 [wr_is_comment] => 1 [wr_comment] => 2 [wr_comment_reply] => [ca_name] => [wr_option] => [wr_subject] => [wr_content] => 아이씨 나도 할걸... 다시 만나자고 할려고 헤어진 전여친 집에 갔다가... 올때 생리대 사오라고 하고 내가 있는데도 평소 습관대로 화장실 문 열어놓고 똥도 누고... 같이 밥도 먹고 밥 먹고 졸리다고 자길래 옆에 누워서 스킨쉽 하니 헤어졌는데 머하는 짓이냐며 화내서 그만 뒀는데... 아깝네 [wr_link1] => [wr_link2] => [wr_link1_hit] => 0 [wr_link2_hit] => 0 [wr_hit] => 0 [wr_good] => 7 [wr_nogood] => 0 [mb_id] => kakao_804b07b8 [wr_password] => *F374C4302CD14B32A9A171672802C02D4AD4EA22 [wr_name] => 환골탈태 [wr_email] => [wr_homepage] => [wr_datetime] => 2023-07-03 17:31:04 [wr_file] => 0 [wr_last] => [wr_ip] => 121.55.178.147 [wr_facebook_user] => [wr_twitter_user] => [articleid] => [wr_1] => [wr_2] => [wr_3] => [wr_4] => [wr_5] => [wr_6] => [wr_7] => [wr_8] => [wr_9] => [wr_10] => [as_type] => 0 [as_shingo] => 0 [as_img] => 0 [as_list] => 0 [as_publish] => 0 [as_extra] => 0 [as_extend] => 0 [as_level] => 74 [as_download] => 0 [as_down] => 0 [as_view] => 0 [as_lucky] => 0 [as_poll] => 0 [as_star_score] => 0 [as_choice] => 0 [as_choice_cnt] => 0 [as_re_mb] => [as_re_name] => [as_tag] => [as_map] => [as_icon] => [as_thumb] => [as_video] => [as_update] => [as_star_cnt] => 1 [ast_read] => 0 [ast_adlist_edate] => 0 [ast_adtop_edate] => 0 [ast_extend] => [ast_ultra_extend] => [wr_besttime] => 2023-07-08 16:47:00.296252 [name] =>

gom [is_lock] => [reply_name] => [content1] => 역시 개검. [content] => 역시 개검. [is_secret] => [date] => 1688372324 [datetime] => 23-07-03 17:18 [best] => [ip] => 117.♡.2.130 [is_reply] => [is_edit] => [is_del] => ) )

최상의서비스 2023.07.15 17:44

헤어졌잖아... 헤어졌는데 왜 전애인을 다시 찾아 ?
도대체 무슨 마음으로 찾는것이고
받아준것일까?

DABIN 2023.07.15 09:13

엥???

페인 2023.07.07 02:24

돈 필요했나보네...

김1 2023.07.04 22:02

헐..

이쁘다 2023.07.04 21:58

그럼 같이살지 말아야지

Liatris 2023.07.04 18:53

그집에 들어가서 산다고..?

노란딸기 2023.07.04 00:14

사겻다가 헤어진걸 연인관계라고하나? 이혼한 배우자도 포함?

야봉 2023.07.03 17:55

소설인가?

환골탈태 2023.07.03 17:31

아이씨 나도 할걸...
다시 만나자고 할려고 헤어진 전여친 집에 갔다가... 올때 생리대 사오라고 하고
내가 있는데도 평소 습관대로 화장실 문 열어놓고 똥도 누고...
같이 밥도 먹고 밥 먹고 졸리다고 자길래 옆에 누워서 스킨쉽 하니 헤어졌는데 머하는 짓이냐며 화내서 그만 뒀는데...
아깝네